(Through 2012 season)
1. Tim Roth-Winamac (33 years): 202-132 .605
2. Kirk Kennedy-NJSP (23 years): 165-96 .632
3. Andy Thomas (14 years)-Culver: 86-60 .589
4. Dan Klimczak (8 years)-South Central: 66-14 .825
5. Darren Rodriguez (6 years)-West Central: 24-29 .452
6. Chris McGowen-Knox (2 years): 2-8 .200
7. Dave Sharpe-John Glenn (1 year): 0-0 .000